After more than two decades of exploring different musical directions, from guitar-driven post-punk to expansive electronic soundscapes, Editors are returning to a more organic approach with their eighth studio album, “Surface, Echo & Sound”. For drummer Ed Lay, the record marks a particularly rewarding return to playing together in a room, rediscovering the energy of the band’s earliest rehearsals.
Ahead of the album’s release, we spoke to Ed about the making of the new record, the band’s musical evolution, the challenges of balancing acoustic drums with electronics, the artists who inspired him, and the friendships that have kept Editors together for twenty-five years. We also discussed the band’s special relationship with Polish audiences, his memories of Poland – including a rather unexpected connection with Polish football stadiums – and the creative freedom that continues to make the future of Editors so exciting.
Interview by Matt Sakson.
“It Made Me Feel Young Again”
MATT: Your new album, “Surface, Echo & Sound”, feels almost like a reaction to your previous record, “EBM”. That album pushed Editors further into electronic and programmed territory, whereas this time you’ve gone back to five people playing together in a room. From a drummer’s perspective, did it feel like rediscovering something that had been missing from the band for a while?
ED: In terms of rediscovering something that’s been missing, I wouldn’t say that. What I would say is that it’s been invigorating. It’s been a real joy to be able to get back behind an acoustic kit and play with the band.
Certainly, on the last record, “EBM”, it wasn’t entirely a choice. It was a necessity, because that album was almost completely written by sending each other files over the internet during the COVID pandemic. So it was a necessary way of kick-starting the writing process for that record. And, you know, having Ben Power – Blanck Mass – in the band, with his unbelievable work ethic, his imagination and his general vibe and enthusiasm for creating music in the way he does, I didn’t feel like I needed to get involved with that side of things as much until we got into the studio.
So it was almost cathartic to just play regular drums on “EBM” and try to mould it into something that was both mechanical and human, and find a balance between the two. But it was so gratifying on this record to just say, “We don’t even have to think about programming. Let’s try and do everything on a real kit!” You know, it’s a little bit like going back to the first rehearsal room we had twenty-five years ago in Birmingham. So that made me feel kind of young again, I suppose.
MATT: Before this conversation, I read a few interviews with you guys. In one of them, Justin said that on this album, a lot of the rhythm actually comes from Tom’s mandolin and acoustic guitar just as much as from the drums. As a drummer, what was it like building your parts around instruments we wouldn’t normally consider the rhythmic backbone of an Editors record?
ED: Absolutely. Some of the very beginnings of songs were based on Tom just sitting there with his mandolin, hammering out a rhythm in the middle of the room, maybe putting it through an amplifier, and then seeing what we could do to support that.
And yeah, I found it really fun, really gratifying. I’m not jealous at all about not being the one who sets the rhythm of a song. That’s never been what I feel my role in the band is. I feel my role is to support Tom, to make his initial idea of what a song could become into a reality, and then maybe add some texture and energy to that. And I think we all obviously have to put our own individual little sprinkle of style on a song. But yeah, I definitely didn’t find it frustrating. I found it a really, really joyful experience.
Finding Power in Simplicity
MATT: This time Justin produced and engineered the album himself, so there wasn’t an outside producer coming in and telling you what you should sound like. Did that give the five of you more freedom, or can having nobody from outside the band to say, “Stop, this is finished!” or “Do it differently!” actually make things more difficult?
ED: I think there are probably elements of both, because this is actually the third record that Justin has had some sort of producer role in. I think on this one, he was less in charge of trying to piece things together – you know, file management, or working out which synth to pick from a selection of twenty on the last record, or whatever.
It was more a case of him being able to create space on the record and say, “Look, all we need is one part. One part from you, one part from you, one sound.” Rather than multilayering and overcomplicating the sound, we were able to strip it back. And I think it sounds more powerful because of that.
It’s also a product of how we wrote, because we were writing in the studio where we eventually recorded. So we were almost writing while already being set up to go straight into recording anyway. To break up that process by getting another producer in, or somebody from out of town to come and be our engineer, would have brought things to a halt. And I think we all felt we wanted to just keep moving forward. So we decided it would be absolutely the best thing for Justin to be creatively at the helm of this and become the producer. And I think he thrived in that role.
MATT: I’d certainly agree with that after listening to this wonderful album. I like it very much! I can hear some Springsteen-esque influences on it – for example, in the song “Rescue”. Is there a story behind that particular track that you’d like to share with our readers?
ED: With that song specifically, we really wanted to make it sound muscular. It’s quite spacious, and we wanted to get the most out of the room we were recording in. We were basically recording it live.
And the room was fantastic! It was this new studio that somebody had created about ten years ago, and they’d built it for themselves. They had stacks and stacks of money, and they made this studio in the middle of nowhere, in an industrial unit. They spent tons of money making it look gorgeous. It sounded brilliant. The acoustic treatment was wonderful, and it was a wonderful space.
But nobody was using it because the owner had sort of lost interest and tried to sell it. And nobody was interested because everybody just makes music at home on laptops and stuff now. They didn’t want a big studio to maintain. But we were just so lucky that we found it. We thought, “Well, this is kind of the best room we could wish for in the UK.” You put a drum kit in the middle of it and it just sounds instantly great.
So we really wanted, especially on that song, to make the room an instrument. Part of the sound of that song comes from the way things reverberate in there. And that was a really cool song to record in that room because it just gave it a lot of weight and gravitas. But yeah, there’s that kind of Springsteen-esque grandeur, I suppose. We weren’t necessarily referencing Springsteen, but there’s nobody better. So I’m glad it sounds like it’s in a similar world. That’s a good compliment.
An Old Song with a Special History
MATT: It’s definitely one of the greatest tracks on the record. Another one is “Much Love”, which apparently has a surprisingly long history, going all the way back to the period after “In This Light and on This Evening”. What was it like bringing such an old song back to life? Could you still remember the people you were, and the band Editors were, when you first started experimenting with it?
ED: Oh, definitely! And it’s quite poignant because it was a time when Tom, Russell and I were working as a three-piece. It was a bizarre time because we were losing our guitarist at the time, Chris. We’d decided we didn’t want to move forward with him in the band.
So we were finding our own way, experimenting with different sounds and seeing whether we’d be able to carry on as a band without him. We were working on that song and we didn’t nail it, but we definitely felt good about it. We felt that if we could make these kinds of songs without Chris, then we were in a good place. We didn’t need to quit. Everything wasn’t suddenly a massive crisis just because we’d lost a member.
It was part of our history that helped us bring Justin and Elliott into the band and move forward as a slightly different band, you know? I don’t specifically remember the parts I played, but I don’t think it’s that similar now to how we were jamming around with it in the room at that time. But yeah, that song has a good soul to it.
“Fyfe Ewing Was Probably My Biggest Influence”
MATT: Since we’ve already gone back into the past a little, I’d like to dig even further into your early days. Which drummers originally inspired you to pick up the sticks? And looking back at your career with Editors, can you still hear any of those early influences in your own playing, or have you developed a style that’s entirely your own?
ED: I don’t think I’ve developed a style that’s entirely my own! But I did love American rock drummers when I was growing up. I think Matt Cameron is a wonderful player, both with Soundgarden and Pearl Jam. There was also a Northern Irish band called Therapy?, who were quite prominent in the ’90s and whom I was really keen on.
And the way their drummer, Fyfe Ewing, hit the drums just blew me away. They were the first band I ever saw live, so I think that left a massive impression on me. The power and strength of his playing were pretty remarkable. And he liked using disco beats as well. So I think I learned a lot of my style from listening to him as a drummer. He’s probably my biggest influence.
What Makes Editors Sound Like Editors?
MATT: Editors have changed musical direction quite dramatically several times over the years – from the guitar-driven sound of “The Back Room”, through the electronics of “In This Light and on This Evening”, all the way to “EBM”. And now you’re back to something much more organic. When you hear a new Editors song for the first time after the whole production and mixing process, is there still something that immediately tells you, “Yes, this is us!”? What actually defines Editors to you after all these years?
ED: A huge part of it is Tom and his voice and his delivery. I mean, he’s been quite exploratory with his voice over the last few albums, pushing things in different directions, learning different ways of singing, singing in falsetto and using his range as an instrument. So yeah, I think Tom is absolutely the key to who we are.
But then Russell and I, as a rhythm section, are quite identifiable, I think. I love the way Russell plays bass. His rolling basslines are quite quirky, but melancholic at the same time. I’ve always been a fan of that, and I always feel like we’ve locked in really well.
You know, he was the first person I met at university when we went there. So he was the first person out of everybody in the band that I bonded with. And I thought, “Yeah, I like this guy. I want to spend lots of time with him.” Which is really lucky, because now we’ve spent twenty-five years together! So it helps to bond with people immediately, I suppose, when you’re in a band. Become friends first and then impart your musical wisdom upon each other. But going back to the main question – Tom is the key.
MATT: It’s been over twenty years since “The Back Room”, and you’re one of only three members who’ve been there throughout the entire journey – Tom, Russell and yourself, as you’ve just mentioned. When you look at Editors today, what do you think has changed the most about the relationship between the three of you compared with those early days? And what, perhaps surprisingly, hasn’t changed at all?
ED: It’s really hard to say because obviously our entire lives were dominated by the band in the early days. We were working to make money so we could rehearse, make new songs and go out and gig, and maybe have a shot at being in a band full-time.
We always wanted to be a career band, so we’ve got exactly what we wanted out of that. We’ve carried on and always made our decisions based on long-term rather than short-term gains. So we’ve always been quite pragmatic and sensible in our discussions about music and how we present ourselves as a band.
I think we’ve always been quite keen not to overshare, to stay a bit in the background, not to be too heavy with our opinions about people. Just to be a bit subtle, I suppose. And I think we’re kind of like that as friends. We don’t overshare with each other. We don’t ring each other up every day. We’re not a group that’s in a gang all the time.
When we go out on tour, we have an amazing time together, but we need our own space to survive and process things. We’re quite different as individuals, but I think that makes us more exciting as a group when we get together.
MATT: So that’s your way of surviving in the same band for so many years, I guess!
ED: Yeah, yeah! Like I say, we socialise, absolutely, and there’s nothing we enjoy more than talking about music or other interesting things – sport, art, whatever it is. But we all have our own distinct lives, and I think that should be celebrated.
“Simple Things Take a Lot of Time to Perfect”
MATT: As we’ve already established, over the years Editors have gone from very physical, almost post-punk drumming to songs dominated by electronics, and now back towards live instrumentation. Which Editors album has challenged you the most as a drummer? Not necessarily in a technical sense, but in terms of finding the right place for yourself within the music?
ED: I think probably “Violence”, I would say. We wrote that record in a room without a drum kit in it, so we were relying heavily on computer programming and drum machines.
And then Ben – Ben from Blanck Mass – got involved as a co-producer, and he brought in more rhythms, more synthesisers and more parts. So it kind of grew massively. Then we went into the studio with a producer who wanted to make it more natural. So that was quite difficult at that point, trying to work out where I was heading. I maybe felt a little bit confused at times.
And then trying to translate that into the live show has probably been the most confusing part. I don’t think it’s that strange, from this point of view, that we don’t play much of that record live. And I think that’s maybe because it felt a bit complex. It’s quite hard to get a lot of enjoyment out of something that feels really complicated when you’re on stage.
So this new album, “Surface, Echo & Sound”, comes from a place of all of us being in a room and playing the tune together, and it feels simple. And simple is not a derogatory thing. You know, simple things take a lot of time to perfect. But essentially, the ingredients are drums, bass, guitar and vocals. And that’s just a classic combination. It works for a reason.
Berlin, Poland and the Magic of Stodoła
MATT: The new album comes out this Friday, and you’re playing a show in Berlin on the same day. Was it a deliberate choice to play your first show after the record’s release in a city with such a strong musical identity? I’m curious whether there’s a special connection between Editors and Berlin, or whether it was simply a matter of logistics this time.
ED: It was simply a matter of logistics. But I wouldn’t say that we don’t have a strong connection with Berlin. I remember we did an album launch campaign and played a venue called SO36, which is a legendary rock club in Kreuzberg. That was one of the most enjoyable shows I’ve ever played. It was hot and sweaty and vibrant. And yeah, that was a remarkable time.
We’ve had some wonderful gigs in Berlin. We’re going back there to play Columbiahalle in the not-too-distant future. I think it’s in March. So yeah, there’s definitely a feeling of connection with Berlin, but on this occasion, it’s a happy accident.
MATT: Speaking of strong connections, Editors have always enjoyed a very special relationship with Polish audiences. As far as I know, you’ve already played in Poland more than twenty times! And now you’re coming back twice in the next few months – first for the Inside Seaside Festival in Gdańsk in just three weeks, and then for a headline show in Warsaw in February. From your perspective, is there something that makes Polish audiences stand out?
ED: Oh yeah, I love playing in Poland – especially Stodoła, where we’re playing in Warsaw. To me, it’s one of the most outstanding venues we’ve played throughout our career. It’s just got such a vibe about it, such an intensity! Everybody turns up and you can feel the energy. I don’t know, there’s something about it. There’s a bit of magic to it. So I’m really excited that we’re playing that venue again.
Inside Seaside – that’s a festival we’ve never played. We’ve been up in Gdańsk before. I think there’s a really big outdoor festival there…
MATT: You mean Open’er, I guess!
ED: Yeah, Open’er! We’ve played that. We’ve definitely played there before. But I don’t think we’ve done our own show in Gdańsk, which is a bit of a shame. This will feel a little bit more like our own show.
I don’t know what it is about Polish audiences, but they just get us. They get us as a band who like to write music about quite dark things, with quite emotional connotations to our songs. It’s just something that’s definitely been there from the start, from our early shows. I’m a bit disappointed we’re not playing more Polish shows on the tour. It would be nice to maybe play in Poznań or Kraków. We’ve been to many towns and we’ve always had a great experience there.
MATT: So hopefully you’ll be able to come back next summer or autumn!
ED: That would be great. I mean, this definitely won’t be the last time we’re touring this record. I’d like to think we’ll be doing a whole lot more. And who knows whether we’ll be doing full tours? But in terms of festivals or other appearances, even one-off appearances, I’d be delighted.
Football, Polish Bars and Life on Tour
MATT: Fingers crossed, then! And since we’re already talking about Poland, do you have any particular memories of the country itself – experiences from your previous visits, not necessarily connected with music, that you’d like to share with our readers?
ED: Yeah. In terms of the reception we’ve had, it’s just been remarkable. Really friendly people, great culture, great bars. The bars are fantastic! I’ve always had really nice, fun nights out in Polish bars.
I remember we were in Poznań and I managed to watch a game in some random sports bar. My favourite football team, Ipswich Town, was playing, and I was able to watch the broadcast there in Poland. This was at a time when we were way worse and weren’t even in the Premier League. So it would have been very difficult to find us on television!
By the way, I usually try to seek out football stadiums when I’m on tour. I like to get up, leave the venue, go for a run and try to run around the football stadium and back to the venue. So that’s always kind of cool. I’ve done the Legia Warsaw stadium when we played in Warsaw last time. So I’ll try to run around that again.
But getting back to my memories of Poland – I just remember really friendly people who want you to be there and want you to have a good experience of the town you’re in. And that’s all you want when you’re on tour. That’s absolutely all you want. You want acceptance. You want a friendly face, and you want to have a good show, especially in a club like Stodoła. You know, it’s really one of the highlights. When I look at the list of shows we’re going to be playing, it’s one of the highlights on there. So I can’t wait for it.
Finding the Right Balance in the Setlist
MATT: That’s fantastic to hear! You’ve reached a point where your catalogue is enormous, but you clearly don’t want to become a nostalgia band playing the same songs all the time. With a new record coming out, how difficult is it to put together a live set these days? Are there songs you personally love playing so much that you think, “There’s no way we’re dropping this one!”? And, at the same time, are there songs you’ve played so many times that you’d rather give them a rest, at least for a while?
ED: Yeah, there are always those songs. But they’re the songs that have made you popular and made people want to come and see you in the first place.
You don’t want to disappoint anyone, but somebody’s always going to miss out on hearing the songs they want. You know, whether you’re really keen on the big hits – there are probably one or two we wouldn’t play – or you just like the really obscure B-sides, maybe you’ll get lucky, but you’re never going to get the exact setlist you dream of.
I think that’s good, though. Variety is key. You want to be surprised by a song we might choose. And we do spend a lot of time trying to hone a setlist before we go out on tour, working out what’s going to fit the general feel of the show we’re trying to put together. Especially now that we’ve gone back, as you say, to a more organic and natural band sound for this record, I wouldn’t be surprised if we tried to build the set around that feel a little bit more than we have over the last couple of years with “EBM”.
“The Most Incredible Feeling for a Band”
MATT: After more than twenty years, eight albums and so many different versions of the band, what can still genuinely surprise or excite you about being part of Editors?
ED: The fact that we’re now coming to a point where we’re going to be releasing our eighth record, and I couldn’t definitively tell you what type of music we’ll be playing on the next one. That’s exciting. That’s cool!
Even if this album were the most successful album we’ve ever done – I mean, I’m not going to say it will be – but even if it were, would the next record just be another version of it? It certainly wouldn’t! So that’s nice. It keeps us interested. It keeps us enjoying each other’s company. And we’ll just do what we feel we need to do.
We’re not under any pressure from a record label. We’re not under any pressure from management. They’re kind of like, “Look, just do what you want to do.” And that is just the most incredible feeling for a band – to be able to have that control and that liberty, I suppose.
MATT: That’s fantastic. And it must be a wonderful feeling to be able to rediscover yourself, both as a person and as a band, with every new record.
ED: One hundred per cent! This is the best feeling.
“I Can’t Wait to Be Back in Poland”
MATT: Finally, as we’re reaching the inevitable end of this interview, is there anything you’d like to share from your heart with your Polish fans, who are eagerly waiting for your upcoming shows here?
ED: I think I’ve made it pretty clear how much I enjoy both being in Poland and playing in Poland. I think it’s a wonderful place for freedom, freedom of thought and enjoying culture. I think everybody I’ve encountered there has just been so enthusiastic about live music. And that, to me, is my world. I’m glad to share it with people who are so enthusiastic. I know the rest of the band can’t wait either.
And we haven’t got long to wait. We’ve only got a couple of weeks and we’ll be flying out on a horrible Wizz Air flight to Gdańsk! (laughs) Just kidding, it won’t be horrible. It’ll be fine, but it’s very early in the morning.
MATT: You don’t have to explain anything! I’ve taken quite a few flights from Poland to the UK this year already, and there’s usually a problem with something. The bags and what you’ve got in them, for example. I only travel with my camera and a few lenses, and that’s usually enough to cause problems with airport security. So I can only imagine what it’s like when they see a guitar, a drum kit and everything else!
ED: I’ll tell you what, kick drum pedals – those blow people’s minds! They’re like, “What is this?” That’s kind of fun to deal with every time!